Why STREET FIGHTER X TEKKEN Didn’t Work

Every fighting game fan remembers where they were when two of Japan’s biggest fighting franchises announced the biggest crossover of all time! The likes of Ryu and Chun Li facing of against Jin and the Mishima clan was something of a dream. Fast forward a few years later and Street Fighter X Tekken is rarely spoken of and pretty much shunned by the fighting game community. The fact that Capcom went back to release another edition of Street Fighter 4  just proves how unpopular SFXT has become.

Street Fighter's World Warriors versus Tekken's King of the Iron First! It was a dream roster.

Street Fighter’s World Warriors versus Tekken’s Kings of the Iron First! Only 14 years in the making.

The World’s Finest

As a fan of both, I can say that Street Fighter and Tekken are the best selling 2D and 3D fighting games respectively for good reason albeit different reasons. Street Fighter is known for its diverse cast of characters ; each offering their own distinct style of how to play the game. As a Vega player, I would approach a match against powerhouse Zangief much differently than I would against the more agile Cammy.

Tekken is a different kettle of fish but equally as good if not better. Gamplay-wise it’s more close-quarters but with an overwhelming number of attacks and option’ much like a game of chess. Merging the styles of Street Fighter and Tekken was always going to be difficult and while this game isn’t terrible; what we have ended up with is a poorer game than either Street Fighter or Tekken.

On the surface Street Fighter X Tekken is your typical Street Fighter: based on the Street Fighter 4 engine, played on a 2D plane with the traditional 6-button layout but with an additional layer of Tekken thrown in. The Tekken cast have had their 80+ movelists trimmed to match Street Fighter’s characters.

kicks

Tekken characters have had their large movelists trimmed to in order to match those of the Street Fighter cast.

Some of those characters fit in better than others and some characters, like Lili, even suit the wackier style of Street Fighter than their own game. It’s when the game attempts to add Tekken elements with Street Fighter where things start to go south. What it actually does is eliminate the good things that make each franchise stand out.

The best of both worlds?

In an effort to make the game more accessible and to incorporate Tekken’s more string-orientated style; Capcom introduced the “Cross Rush” an identical combo string for every character and I mean literally the same combination. Not only did this particular combo string become overly useful, to the point where its ever-present in any match no matter what the level, but by giving everyone this overused combo; characters lost their individuality as everyone fights like everyone else hurting what makes Street Fighter what it is.

sfxt posion

Giving everyone the same of options really hurt a game that prides itself over the diversity of it’s characters.

One thing that Tekken is known for is its infamous lengthy juggle combos compared to Street Fighter’s shorter combos and true to form; SFXT incorporates Tekken-style juggle combos but Tekken is a lot more than that juggles. Tekken’s lengthy juggles evened out by its heavy “metagame”. “Metagame” is a combination of mix-ups, guessing games, Okemi and other technical jazz. Essentially, it’s the player who wins the “metagame” that wins the right to perform a juggle combo. It’s a game where you have to work for your heavy combos as generally only slower, riskier moves will put your opponent in a juggle stage. High risk, High rewards.

In the traditional Street Fighter games combos can start from easy-to-hit quick, light attacks but are usually shorter. Low Risk, Low rewards. In their own way both series’ have a fair risk/rewards system. However Street Fighter X Tekken combines Street Fighter’s simpler “metagame” with Tekken’s lengthier combos and ends up feeling rather lopsided. Low Risk/High Reward. Combos being so easy to perform alongside the fact that they are even longer than Tekken’s means they’ve become very prominent and repetitive to the point where the game becomes one dimensional and boring.

There a lot of awkward looking moves here in this game. Particular the launcher of the SF characters. Certain attack won't look good when confined to a 2D plane.

There a lot of awkward looking moves in this game and you’ll be seeing them a lot.

The game borrows Tekken’s juggling but using Street Fighter’s smaller movelist makes for weaker metagame. The guessing game here is so limited and to be fun the Tekken-style gameplay needs it. To make matters worse most Street Fighter attacks are traditionally designed and animated to poke horizontally meaning a lot of these attacks weren’t animated to look like they can juggle opponents and as I said these combos are quite prominent.

Final Round

In an attempt to combine the best features of the two fighting game series’ Street Fighter X Tekken ends up produces a dinky experience. It’s Tekken without the options to allow for heavy “metagame”. It’s Street Fighter without the unique character styles and match ups. As a video game casual fun can be had from this but as the serious fighting experience we were expecting it is very poor. The trailers were more exciting than the actual game. SFXT was supposed to be the best of both worlds but your typical Street Fighter or Tekken is much better than this.

Edited by Ayrton Noye George
The art, the concept, the trailers, the HYPE were better than the game itself. Disappointing.

The art, the concept, the trailers, the HYPE were better than the game itself. Sorry Ryu, Kazuya and co. This was disappointing.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Why STREET FIGHTER X TEKKEN Didn’t Work

    • Both good points but I wanted to stick purely gameplay mechanics which the DLC isn’t apart of.

      As for the Time Outs, I wouldn’t say its low damage output it’s more that everyone (in theory) has double the health.
      Street Fighter matches generally less offensive and last longer than 3D fighters like Tekken so when you add an additional health bar into the mix this is what you get. I focused on what bothered me the most.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s